Appendices 12B, 12C, and 12D

Sentencing Parameters and Criteria

These three appendices govern the term of confinement a military judge adjudges under R.C.M. 1002. Appendix 12C assigns each offense a category, Appendix 12B gives each category a range of confinement, and Appendix 12D states the criteria for the offenses that have no range.

12B — Parameter table 12C — Offense category chart 12D — Sentencing criteria

HOW TO READ THIS PAGE

An offense with a parameter

“When an offense is subject to sentencing parameters, the military judge shall sentence the accused for that offense within the applicable parameter, unless the military judge finds specific facts that warrant a sentence outside the applicable parameter. If the military judge imposes a sentence outside a sentencing parameter, the military judge shall include in the record a written statement of the factual basis for the sentence.” — R.C.M. 1002(a)(2)(B)

An offense with criteria

“When an offense is subject to sentencing criteria, the military judge shall consider the applicable sentencing criteria in determining the sentence for that offense.” — R.C.M. 1002(a)(2)(A)

Limits on the range

  • The maximum punishment caps the range. Where an offense’s maximum confinement is lower than the top of its category, the lower figure controls (the Appendix 12B note, below). The maximums “apply notwithstanding any applicable sentencing parameter” (R.C.M. 1003(c)(1)(A)(i)). The maximum punishment chart lists them.
  • A special court-martial may adjudge no more than 12 months. For a Category 3 offense or greater, that jurisdictional maximum is the parameter.
  • “Dependent on underlying offense” means that the offense takes the category of the offense beneath it, such as the offense attempted or solicited.
  • A plea agreement with a sentence limitation binds the court-martial once the military judge accepts it. The military judge may reject an agreement that proposes a plainly unreasonable sentence (R.C.M. 1002(a)(3)).
  • The date of the offense decides which rules apply. The parameters and criteria govern only where every offense of conviction was committed after 27 December 2023. Where any offense was committed on or before that date, the rules in effect before 28 December 2023 apply, and the accused makes an election of sentencing rules (R.C.M. 925(c)).
Appendix 12B

Sentencing Parameter Table — Confinement Range Categories

Offense category Months
Category 1 0–12
Category 2 1–36
Category 3 30–120
Category 4 120–240
Category 5 240–480
Category 6 Confinement for life with eligibility for parole

Note: For all above categories, if the confinement portion of the maximum authorized punishment for the offense is less than the Offense Category’s confinement maximum, the lesser confinement portion of the maximum authorized punishment shall control as the recommended maximum confinement time for that offense. At a special court-martial, for an offense that is a category 3 offense or greater, the jurisdictional maximum period of confinement (12 months) constitutes the parameters; however, the military judge may impose a period of confinement less than the jurisdictional maximum period of confinement upon finding specific facts that warrant such a sentence.

Select a category to list every offense assigned to it.

Appendix 12C

Offense Category Chart

Reset
Article Offense Offense category Confinement range
90 Willfully disobeying superior commissioned officer
In time of war Criteria None; criteria apply
Other Category 2 1–36 months

The range shown is the category’s. The offense’s maximum confinement replaces the top of the range where it is lower, and at a special court-martial the parameter for a Category 3 offense or greater is 12 months.

Appendix 12D

Sentencing Criteria

The military judge shall consider the sentencing criteria established for the following offenses:

Only the criteria for Article 90 are shown. Show all 18 criteria offenses.

Article 90. Willfully disobeying a lawful order of superior commissioned officer (in time of war)

  • The age and experience of the accused;
  • Any mental impairment or deficiency of the accused;
  • Whether the offense disrupted or, in any way, impacted the operations of any organization;
  • Whether the offense was committed to avoid the movement of a vessel or hazardous duty or shirk important service;
  • Whether the offense was committed before or in the presence of the enemy;
  • Whether the offense was committed before or in the presence of other members of the accused's or the superior commissioned officer's unit;
  • Whether the offense caused damage to the national security of the United States, regardless of whether the accused intended such damage;
  • The status of the superior commissioned officer and command relationship to the accused;
  • Whether the accused abused a position of trust or authority, or used specialized skill or training, in a manner that significantly facilitated the offense;
  • Whether the offense was committed in a way that created, or under circumstances creating, a substantial risk of bodily harm or death to any person;
  • Whether the offense involved the conscious or reckless disregard of a risk of death or serious bodily harm to any person;
  • Whether the offense involved possession of a dangerous weapon; and
  • Whether the offense was committed in territory in which the United States or an ally of the United States was then an occupying power or in which the United States Armed Forces were then engaged in a contingency operation or active hostilities.
Not legal advice. This page reproduces Appendices 12B, 12C, and 12D of the Manual for Courts-Martial (2024 edition). The governing provisions are R.C.M. 1002, R.C.M. 1003, and Article 56. The offense’s maximum punishment, the jurisdictional limits of the court-martial, any mandatory minimum, and any plea agreement also limit a sentence. Verify against the current Manual and consult a judge advocate or qualified counsel.